64. Secondary Dominants (7): Practice 3 "Deliberately Not Resolving (2)"

Music Theory for BeginnersPublished 2018.09.17Updated 2026.07.17

Learning More About Progressions That Don't Resolve

Last time, we focused on places where a secondary dominant, which until then had resolved V→I, led to a completely different chord.

Let's listen to the audio from last time.

Until now, I7 had progressed to IV...

V7/IV

C7→Fmaj7

C→F

C7→F

As at the green arrows, it progressed to a different chord.
The new point is that it didn't sound odd even though it didn't resolve.

Examples That Don't Resolve

Now let's listen to a variety of examples.
We'll check everything in Key = C.

Here, E7 is placed right before the chorus.
This is a pattern that starts from I of A minor, the relative key of C major, in other words the Am chord.

In the next example, the chord before the chorus is also E7.

When you hear E7, you'd normally expect Am or Am7 to follow and the song to turn minor.
But here, it deliberately defies that expectation and moves into the so-called "Royal Road progression" starting on Fmaj7.

Next, let's try using the doppel dominant (V/V).
First, the usual way: D7 progresses to G.

Now let's progress D7 to F instead.
We ended with II-V-I.

Here too, you'd normally expect G or G7 to follow, but defying that expectation gives a different impression.

Next, let's check using I7, which also appeared last time.
First, let's resolve it as usual to IV, F major.

Next, as we analyzed last time, let's progress C7 to Bm7b5.

Connecting to a minor II-V-I gives the impression that "this song was actually in minor."

We once explained that "if the diatonic chords are a family, secondary dominants are like relatives," and as the examples above show, they can actually blend into the music naturally even without progressing to the expected resolution.

Besides the dominant of the relative key, the dominants of the closely related dominant key and subdominant key are also easy to use, so try those first.

When you find a secondary dominant that doesn't resolve while analyzing songs, actively add it to your toolbox.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q1. When a secondary dominant doesn't resolve, can you go to any chord without it sounding odd?

No. Secondary dominants of the relative key, the dominant key and the subdominant key are the most effective. The article recommends trying these closely related progressions first; not every chord progression will work.

Q2. What effect does a pattern where E7 doesn't progress to Am have?

By defying the listener's expectation and moving into the Royal Road progression starting on Fmaj7, you can give the song a fresh impression and tension. Deliberately shifting expectations lets you create a more memorable melodic development.

Q3. When I find an unresolved secondary dominant while analyzing a song, how should I use it?

We recommend actively adding that progression pattern to your production toolbox and referring to it in future compositions. Learning techniques from existing songs improves practical, natural composing skills.